Skip to main content

Posts

Unintended Consequences. Why Britain Can’t Build.

This post has been kindly provided by David Cross , the CEO at Sky House , and, offering as it does an honest assessment of the plight of the SME builder, I would urge everybody involved in planning and development to take the time to first read it and then to think about how we got here and what we can do about it. In the 26 years I have been an architect I have watched the slow and almost total demise of the SME developer and housebuilder in slow motion. Layer by layer we have regulated the sector beyond reasonable viability, to the point where building homes in large parts of Britain is becoming a state-sponsored affair. The entrepreneur and maverick developer who was abundant in my early career as an architect is almost gone. The small builders who would pick up awkward little sites and deliver cool urban schemes, conversions or a handful of one-off houses are disappearing too. From 2003 to 2008 my old architectural practice would have had dozens of these small builders as clients....
Recent posts

Podcast episode 187: A Lot of Stick (But Not Much Carrott)

Episode 187 of the podcast s available now via this link below or from the usual podcast platforms. I was in Birmingham recently and caught up whilst there with old friends of the podcast Myles Wild-Smith, Kathryn Ventham and Jacob Bonehill. Myles is a Director at Lichfields, Kathryn is a Senior Director at Twenty5 Planning and Jacob is a Director at Carney Sweeney. In a conversation recorded at the Podcast Room, we talked about what was then the soon-to-be, but is now the mandatory, National Scheme of Delegation; we talked about appealing against non-determination rather than waiting to be called-in; we talked about the extension of the deadline for the submission of local plans under the legacy system; and we talked about SDSs, LGR, Solihull’s Regulation 19 local plan and the West Midland Combined Authority’s Housing & Employment Land Needs Assessment. If you enjoy the episode do please consider bolstering my fragile self-esteem by leaving the podcast a nice rating and a n...

On locally-set planning fees

The pendulum that is the planning system’s legislative and policy framework has swung consistently back and forth since I started working over 25 years ago. Seemingly no incoming administration can resist the temptation of a landmark bill to finally get Britain building or, since 2012, a new NPPF to either also get Britain building or stop Britain building depending upon how bolshy the backbenchers are being. A minor upside of a perpetual reform agenda is a constant supply of content for columnists, bloggers and podcasters, but a major downside is that it absorbs ministerial and civil service time and energy that might otherwise be expended addressing the planning pantomime’s erstwhile Cinderella, which is development management. In this long-neglected corner of the system, despite the additional layer of complexity that each legislative and policy change has added over time, planning applications are essentially being prepared, submitted and determined in the same that I have always k...

Podcast episode 186: Hail To The Chief

Episode 186 of the podcast is available now via this link or from the usual podcast platforms. One of the most common topics of conversation that I was party to at the UKREiiF jamboree in Leeds this year was the need for statutory chief planners. There are perhaps three factors behind that interest in building or strengthening leadership capacity within LPAs. First, the impending programme of devolution and local government reform will create larger teams covering larger geographies that will need to co-operate with newly emerging strategic authorities. Second, more authorities being in no overall control need guiding through the decision-making implications of that. And thirdly, the emerging need to manage the possibly contentious gateway test element of the soon statutory scheme of delegation. A role of statutory status, I also heard suggested in the context of wider LPA capacity and skills issues, might be something to encourage a junior officer to stay in local government and work...

On Mayoral Call-In Powers and VAR

I said something clever the other week and thought it so clever that I made a note to hang a blog on it. Mayoral call-in powers have the potential to do for planning what the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) has done to football. Bear with me... By way of a reminder, the consultation on planning powers for mayors in England that closed earlier this month states the following. One of the key sets of planning powers which all mayors outside London will gain through the implementation of the English Devolution Act are the powers to intervene in relation to applications of potential strategic importance (PSI). These powers enable mayors to ‘call in’ applications allowing them to shape strategic development in their area. In turn, this supports the implementation of their SDS. The Mayor of London has had the full set of powers since 2008, and successive mayors have successfully used them to shape London’s development. The specific powers are: to require LPAs to consult the mayor on PSI applic...

Life on the Front Line IV

Long-serving (long-suffering?) readers of the 50 Shades blog and listeners to the 50 Shades podcast will recall that back in December 2021 I published the first Life on the Front blog , which informed episode 60 of the podcast a short time afterwards. I revisited the theme with a second blog and podcast a year later. The basis of the initial exercise was, at the prompting of a listener, to explore the LPA staffing crisis and, in 'taking the temperature' of the profession, it certainly struck a nerve. That first blog, as of just now, has been viewed 29,775 times, which is much, much more than my usual wittering. The second blog has been viewed 4,141 times as of just now. I did try to revisit the subject with a third blog in July last year, but that got a lot less traction. 50 Shades of Planning is though by planners and for planners and it has been suggested to me that there is an appetite out there to revisit the topic, which I am more than happy to do. So, what is life lik...

Podcast episode 185: Neutral Impact IV

Episode 185 of the podcast is available now via this link or from the usual podcast platforms. When 50 Shades first covered nutrient neutrality in February 2021, I described the process of eutrophication as a bit like the podcast itself: a little niche, but very important. When I published a second episode on it in September 2022 it had grown in significance to the extent that Prime Minister Liz Truss had pledged to “scrap nutrient neutrality rules”. The question that was posed in that second episode, and again in a third episode in June 2024, was how far away is a satisfactory resolution in those parts of the country that have been affected. Well, here we are, planning fans, almost eight years on from the 'Dutch N' judgement in the European Court of Justice, and, whisper it quietly, a satisfactory resolution to the issue that has resulted in 74 LPAs in and around Special Protection Areas withholding planning permission unless the negative impacts of development can be ruled o...